Court Decree Without Lawyer

“Lawyers sometimes do not attend to the court hearings in order to prevent the court’s decision however the court violates the right to defense by not collecting defense evidences” told Lawyer Cinmen.


İstanbul - BIA News Center
20 May 2012, Sunday

According to the law proposal of Justice and Development Party (AKP), the courts will be able to decree in the absence of a lawyer except children trials.

"The prosecutor is a party at the legal proceedings whereas the court is independent"

"According to the new practice, the court will serve a summons to the lawyer and if the lawyer do not attend the hearing despite of this summon, the court will be able to decree and this might create an obstacle against the right to defense in some cases.

"The courts do not collect defense evidences in some cases and this also violates the right to defense.  The hearings are conducted according to the expert reports taken by prosecutor during the investigation.

"The prosecutors also have the right to consult the expert in preparation stage however the court can never move according to the expert reports provided by the prosecutor at the prosecution stage. Because, the prosecutor is a party at the legal proceedings whereas the court is independent."

"Of course this new legislation will adversely affect the right to defense. The court does not collect the defense evidences; this is the key issue and this occurs within the practices of the court, not with legal amendments" told Lawyer Ergin Cinmen,

"The trials prolonged unnecessarily"

AKP declared the reasons of this law proposal as follows:

*The trials are prolonged unnecessarily when the defenders are not present at the final hearings of the complex trials with multiple defendants.

* Therefore, the following issue is introduced through an amendment: "If the public prosecutor announces his opinion about the merit without limiting the right to defense and when the defender is present at the hearing or if the opinion of the court is defender is already announced to the defender, the court will be able to decree in the absence of a lawyer who is not present at the hearing without any acceptable excuse." (EKN)

Independent Communication NetworkIndependent Communication Network comprises more than internet news website bianet.org. It is a continuously unfolding network since 1997 and embraces "Training Drives" for journalists and communication students and NGOs; handbook series, "Radio Programs" for the local media, conferences, forums, international exchange programs.

IPS Communication Foundation (BİA)IPS Communication Foundation is the implementing body for the BIA &bianet.org. Founded in 1993 by four journalists and one human rights activists, has implemented many projects including a BİA, BİA2 and BİA3.

BİA LibraryBİA Library comprises of handbooks series and guides and researches which systemize the theoretical and informative contributions realized during the implementation of programs within the BİA projects. Some of the 15 publications are in English and accessible via bianet.org.

Contact usYou can reach IPS Communication Foundation directors, BİA project coordination, bianet.org editorial board via telephone, fax, e-mail and mail from everywhere on the globe, dispatch information and/or documents and request meetings.